Before you buy or sign
Rental guarantee or managed rental: which should you choose?
A rental guarantee pays you an agreed amount whatever the bookings do. Managed rental pays you what the property actually earns, less the manager’s fee. The first buys certainty, usually priced into the purchase or the split; the second keeps both the upside and the risk with you. Your unit and your building decide which is worth more. This page is for a buyer, or an owner choosing a model; if your guarantee is already ending, the countdown has its own guide.
The four models
What you are actually choosing between.
Most arrangements on the island are one of these, or a negotiated version of one.
A developer’s guaranteed return
A fixed return for a set number of years, paid by the developer or its operator. Where it was higher than the unit really earns, it was generally priced into the purchase: you paid for it up front.
A net guarantee from a manager
The manager pays you an agreed net amount and keeps what the property earns above it. Property Management Phuket publishes this option alongside a rate from 12 percent.
A rental pool
Income is shared across the units in a programme. You are insulated from your own unit’s performance, and a well placed unit subsidises a poorly placed one without you being able to tell which yours is.
Commission management
The manager takes a share of what your property earns, and you see your own unit’s figures every month. Our fee starts at 10 percent.
Side by side
Where the risk sits in each.
The same five questions, asked of each model. Read the contract in front of you against this, because the terms vary more than the names.
| Developer guarantee | Net guarantee | Rental pool | Commission management | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who pays you | The developer or its operator | The manager | The programme, shared across units | Guests, through the platforms, less the fee |
| In a bad year | Fixed, if the payer can pay | Fixed, if the payer can pay | Falls with the building | Falls with your calendar |
| In a good year | Surplus goes to the payer | Surplus goes to the manager | Shared across units | Mostly yours |
| Your own unit’s figures | Usually hidden | Usually hidden | Averaged | Every booking and expense |
| Your own use | Often limited | Often limited | Often limited | Block your dates (with us) |
Who can stop paying
A guarantee is a promise from a company. Ask who that company is, what it owns, and what happens to the payments if it is sold or fails.
Getting out
Read the exit terms and the building’s rules: some buildings require rentals to go through the operator, whatever your contract says.
Being fair about it
When a guarantee is the right choice.
Already own, and your guarantee is about to end? That is a different decision with a deadline on it: the timeline, the contract clauses to check and the handover are in our end-of-guarantee guide.
The unit is weak within its building
Low floor, no view, next to the service lift: a fixed or averaged figure may be worth more to you than that unit’s own results would be.
Certainty matters more than upside
If a predictable amount matters more to you than a higher expected one, that has genuine value, and commission management does not offer it.
The company behind it is solid
A guarantee is only as good as the company paying it. If that company is identifiable, owns real assets and its figures hold up, the certainty you are paying for is real.
Before you sign a guarantee
Five questions to put in writing.
Who exactly pays it?
The company name on the contract, not the brand on the brochure, and what assets stand behind it.
What does the unit really earn?
Ask for your own unit’s occupancy and average rate, not the building average. If they will not provide it, that is information too.
What happens at the end?
Renewal terms, notice, and whether you are free to choose another manager once the period ends.
How many weeks can you use it?
Owner-use limits and blackout periods, in days, in the contract.
What are comparable units doing?
Our free market analysis shows what comparable properties in your area actually booked over twelve months, so you can see what the guarantee is really worth.
Straight answers
What owners ask about guarantees.
What is a rental guarantee in Phuket?
What is a net guarantee?
Is a rental guarantee better than commission management?
Is a high guaranteed return a good sign when buying?
Do you offer a rental guarantee?
What happens when my guarantee ends?
About this page
Who wrote it.
Authors
Written by Silvain, General Director, with Pattama, Operational Director. They run Phuket Property Manager, the property management arm of Empire Estates Phuket Co., Ltd, from Choeng Thale.
Sources
Published terms of the companies named, as recorded in our market review of October 2026. This is not legal or financial advice; a contract you are about to sign belongs with a Thai lawyer.
Reviewed . We update these pages when the practice on the ground changes, not on a schedule.
Talk to the person who would look after your property.
No call centre, no sales team. We keep the portfolio small on purpose.